Vargo Triad Alcohol Stove Review

Overview
The Vargo Triad is a tiny little stove that at 55mm in diameter is
about the same size as the simmer lid of a trangia. With the legs open
the total height is just 60mm. This is a stove that can find space to
fit in any pack. It'll happily sit inside of a mug.
At 28g I still hold out a hope that it will be a good little alcohol
stove.
Indoor Testing
Fuel has to be poured into the stove through the tiny hole in the centre.
You have to do this slowly and you have to fill it until fuel is visible
in the basin. This is tricky to do even with my trangia fuel bottle.
Using an ordinary bottle is to say the least frustrating with fuel going
everywhere.
Once you have the thing filled with fuel then setting it alight is
easy with a match or a lighter. It takes several minutes for the heat
of the fuel in the centre to heat the stove sufficiently that the jets
start to work. Once the jets are lit they will stay lit until the stove
runs out of fuel.
In order to work at all you have to fill the stove up every time to
the brim.
You cannot in practice empty the fuel from the stove and so you have
to always burn it to completion. This seems a little wasteful.
Outdoor Testing
My
first field trip with this stove was somewhat stressful. Trying to fill
it from a tiny little nalgene bottle meant that fuel went everywhere.
I did finally get more fuel in the stove than in the grass...
Once it was lit I found that it was being blown out by light breezes
and that the jets would not fire. I erected an adhoc wind break out
of rocks and pieces of kit. It was a little precarious but it did help.
I did manage to boil the cup (MSR Titanium 400ml) of water but it took
a while and I only achieved a simmer rather than a good healthy boil.
It was only towards the end of the simmer that the jets ignited. I
think even the airflow around the wind shield was preventing ignition.
It did not compare at all well with my normal trusty windproof trangia
(that is much, much heavier).
Early Conclusions
The stove definitely needs a close-fitting windshield. I have built
one and will run another field test. I badly want this stove to work
because it is so light but I fear that I might instead settle for an
ultralight kit based around aTrangia burner.
Priming
After a little research it would appear that the stove needs a little
priming to work best in cooler conditions. The easiest way to prime
the Vargo Triad is to use the same trick that is used with Trangias
- place a small cap of fuel underneath the burner and ignite it. This
is sufficient to boil some of the fuel so that the jets will fire up
within a minute or so.
Looking at the various timings published for this stove my personal
guess is that boil times must be commenced after the stove has been
primed and all jets are burning.
Realistic weights for a cooking system
The stove may weigh only 28g but what do you actually need to carry
in order to boil water?
| Stove |
28g |
| Windscreen (essential) |
30g |
| Plastic fuel bottle (eg Platypus Lil' Nipper + spout) |
30g |
| Fuel |
45g /day? |
| Titanium cup |
50g |
| TOTAL WEIGHT |
183g min |
At less than 200g for that first cup of water it compares very well
with the MSR Pocket Rocket
which started out at 358g for a full cylinder. The big difference between
the two is that the Vargo Triad will take around 15 minutes to boil
a cup of water in the field compared with 2 minutes for the MSR pocket
Rocket. At this point in time I am more inclined to take the MSR stove
and have my drink faster than worry about the extra initial weight.
Of course after 3-4 days on the trial the extra fuel requirements of
the Triad will of course add up so that the weight becomes similar.
|